Toby: I'm starving. Let's grab something to eat.
Spencer: I'm not hungry. I mean, I have a large pit in my stomach, but I'm not hungry.
Toby: Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. You definitely need to eat something. I'm not driving back to Rosewood with low-blood-sugar Spencer. That's worse than no-caffeine Spencer.
Spencer: Wow. Your girlfriend sounds awesome.
Toby: Your parents are gonna work through this, Spencer. They have a lot of history together.
Spencer: That's what's splitting them up.
Spencer: [dancing with Toby] Why would she say that? Why would she say that I never even liked her?
Toby: Oh, because she hasn't always been the easiest person to like.
Spencer: Yeah, but we came here to protect her. That's all any of us have been trying to do for weeks. Years. We basically missed out on our high school experience trying to solve the mystery that is Alison. The only reason we survived is because we had each other.
Toby: Is that what your speech is about? For commencement?
Spencer: Oh, my God. Just forget about the stupid speech. Nobody's ever gonna hear it.
Toby: [about to drive off] Spencer, I don't feel like asking questions, and not when I'm getting answers.
Spencer: [climbing into truck with him] Yeah, and they also feed turkeys lots of tasty treats before they chop their heads off.
Spencer: I'm really, really happy for you, Toby. You deserve love. You deserve that kind of great, big, beautiful love. More than anyone else I know.
Officer: [chuckles] Thank you. I hope that you find the same.
Spencer: [softly] Me, too.
[on her way again... then stops, turns back]
Spencer: Toby? Can I kiss you? One last time? Just to say goodbye.
[shakes her head]
Spencer: Well, I'm not giving up. I don't think that anklet proves anything. He is guilty.
Toby: And you're sure of this?
Spencer: Why are you challenging me?
Toby: Because there was a time when you thought that I murdered Alison. Remember?
Spencer: Toby, who are you building the house for?
Toby: What makes you think I'm building it for somebody?
Spencer: Because I know you.
Toby: [in hospital] Spencer... Jenna wants to talk to you. All of you.
Spencer: [nods] Okay.
[on her way]
Toby: Are you all right?
Spencer: [little sigh] I think so.
Caleb: Wow, when I'm falling for a girl, I, uh usually cook her a meal. You are building her a house.
Toby: So how about you? You, uh... You cooking for anyone?
Toby: That's why I'm here.
Toby: Does that have to do with Hanna? You're still holding on to that?
Caleb: Uh, actually I connected with someone a few years ago. The timing wasn't right and it was just... It-it felt really complicated. It still is pretty complicated.
Toby: For someone who's a straight shooter you're really talking in circles.
Caleb: It's Spencer.
Toby: Do you want me to talk to your Dad?
Spencer: Good luck finding him. He's been avoiding me like the plague.
Toby: Does Alison know? What you think he did to her Mom?
Spencer: Not the kind of information that I wanna arm her with until I know for sure that he did it.
Toby: So, if action is character, then who is Alison now?
Spencer: You've been reading Fitzgerald.
Toby: I've been rereading Fitzgerald. I already know Alison's story, but it's hard to picture her as a victim.
Spencer: She seemed really genuine when she said that what she's been through changed her, and I wanna believe her...
Toby: But you don't.
Spencer: Well, how can I believe a story that I haven't been told? If the truth is in the details, we still don't know what happened to her.
Toby: Hey, Spencer, we wouldn't be us if we didn't believe in second chances, but it's okay to close the door on someone who's toxic.
Spencer: [they have Nigel's phone record] So you think this is where CeCe Drake went when she left town?
Caleb: I can get into it and see what I can find out. But why would she want to ruin Ashley Marin, or hurt Hanna?
Toby: Or the rest of you, for that matter. Could she have helped Wilden set that fire? Or was Wilden helping her?
Spencer: She said that she was leaving town because she was afraid of Wilden. So maybe the truth is that... they set the fire, she killed Wilden, and this set-up is her covering her own tracks.
Toby: Can you think of a reason to believe she's not A?
Spencer: Toby, CeCe visited Mona in Radley.
Toby: [to Caleb] Can you give us a minute?
Caleb: Yeah, just don't start making out or anything.
Spencer: [as she follows Toby, scoffs:] Believe me, I missed him while you two were playing Hardy Boys, but now is not the time.
Spencer: So, what's it like to run away?
Toby: Cold. Didn't you ever run away?
Spencer: Once. I think I was seven. My sister and I had an argument over something and... my parents took Melissa's side.
Toby: What were you fighting about?
Spencer: Some great injustice. I can't remember now.
[scoffs]
Spencer: But they sided with her... so I made a tuna salad sandwich and I ran away.
Toby: And where did you go?
Spencer: The movies. It was something animated. There was a princess and everybody was singing... Then I got lonely... and I ate my tuna salad sandwich and I came home.
Toby: Were your parents worried?
Spencer: They hadn't even noticed I was gone.
Toby: Do me a favor?
Spencer: What?
Toby: If you ever get the urge to run away again... call me first, okay?
Spencer: [smiles] Okay.
[his hand closes over hers, they smile]
Toby: [to Spencer] Pretending not to love you was the hardest thing I've ever done.
Alison: [visiting juvenile detention center] Listen, I drove all the way up here and just got a triple-X pat-down by security. The least you can do, is to save me the trouble of being lied to.
Toby: Why are you so convinced that it's me? I'm pretty sure Jenna would love to see your head on a stick.
Alison: [sneering tone] Jenna would be pretty happy to see anything, I imagine. Your step-sis was going through surgery when some of these were sent. Wanna know how it turned out? She's still combing her hair with an electric toothbrush.
Toby: [disdainful] You can go now.
[bumps against her shoulder on purpose as he dismisses her]
Alison: [yelling] You know, I wasn't the only one outside that garage. Why aren't you harassing my friends?
Toby: You know what? I wish I knew who wrote those notes. I'd offer my services. You and your posse deserve a lot worse.
Alison: I bet you wish you'd kissed me when you had the chance.
Toby: You know that's my shirt.
Spencer: Yeah, and you're never getting it back.
Toby: I don't want it back.
[they kiss]
Toby: You look better in it than I do.
Hanna: It's unbelievable. Ali's in the penalty box, but she's still playing offensive.
Toby: Maybe this is just her being iced out. Getting desperate. But if you actually think there's somebody on the outside helping her...
Hanna: Yeah, totally! There was a fireworks display.
Emily: But maybe she planned that before she was arrested.
Spencer: No way. Someone is helping her.
Aria: What do you mean "someone"? I saw Alison and Holbrook under the mistletoe, and he had his tongue down her throat. It's him!
Hanna: We don't know that for sure. Didn't Tanner say that he was assigned to a case in Pittsburgh?
Toby: He's off it. He had to take a personal leave to take care of his sick dad.
Emily: That's convenient.
Hanna: [to Toby] Can you see if Holbrook's visiting Ali in prison?
Spencer: No, guys, he can't. Why should he be the one who gets thrown headfirst into the lion's den?
Spencer: After what happened with Mona, we all decided it would be smart to get as far away from Alison as possible. God, how can she still decide where I go and what I do? She's behind bars, and we still cannot get far enough away from her. New Mexico, Montana, let's say I do go to the University of Hawaii...
Toby: She'll be here, in jail.
Spencer: Right. And she was able to plant a murder weapon in Mona's backyard for you to find. You don't think that she can book a plane ticket?
Toby: You don't know...
Spencer: You don't know, okay? We are pretty sure that she had help.
Toby: Well, none of us will ever know that for sure, will we?
Toby: Spencer, I know you. When you want answers, you get them.
Spencer: Yeah, well, you might know me, but you don't know my Dad.
[gets up]
Spencer: And when he tells me to mind my own business, that's what I do. So can you just get over it?
Hanna: Okay, fine. I don't know anything. But what about you? Did you forget everything Jenna did to you?
Toby: No. Did you forget what you did to her?
Spencer: Caleb doesn't know that I'm here.
Toby: If you're gonna try and get me...
Spencer: He didn't do it. Okay? He didn't leak it. He's just taking the blame.
Toby: Why?
Spencer: Because A is back.
[as: ]
Spencer: Not A exactly, uh, just some copycat version.
Toby: [softly:] What?
Spencer: Whoever this is, thinks that we know who killed Charlotte, and so they're trying to make our lives miserable because of it. And I'm really sorry, but Yvonne was just collateral damage. And Caleb didn't want to tell you, because he didn't wanna put you at risk.
Toby: [nods] Thank you for telling me.
[as: ]
Toby: How are you? Are you okay?
Spencer: Yeah, I'm okay. I just, um... I really couldn't have you thinking that I would ever judge Yvonne... for making that choice... Not after... you and I... almost had to make that choice.
